|By Tom Hays
November 6, 1998
Vol. 2: Issue 44
Published in Game Developer Magazine, September 1998
DirectMusic's headlines for most people who make games are DLS support for hardware acceleration and MIDI with over a million channels and rock-solid timing. It's a big package, consisting of several major parts that operate on different levels. It's not necessary to use or even understand all of the components to make good use of parts you need.
For starters, DirectMusic replaces Windows' MidiOut technology with a new model. DirectMusic's MIDI support has subsample timing accuracy, allows flexible selection of output ports (including third-party creations), and lets applications inspect, filter, and modify MIDI data as it comes out. The release version will also multiply MIDI 1.0's 16 channels by a healthy 65,536, for a total of 1,048,576 discreet channels (called pChannels within DirectMusic).
The biggest single claim that DirectMusic has to making MIDI relevant again is its support for DLS. According to its developers, the bundled Microsoft Software Synthesizer was using 0.12 percent of the CPU per voice on a Pentium II 266MHz MMX as of late June. These numbers will get a bit worse when reverberation is added (reverberation wasn't included in the API as of this writing, but is scheduled to happen before final release). Under the Win32 Driver Model in Windows 98 and Windows NT, this is open to hardware acceleration by PCI-bus sound cards.
DirectMusic includes a Roland-made General MIDI/GS sound set. However, the really great thing about DLS is that it opens up MIDI in games to a variety of techniques for using samplers that electronic musicians have built up over the years. These range from basic wavetable-style techniques (but with any choice of sample data) to sampling entire musical phrases and triggering them via MIDI commands.
If MIDI is a dirty word for many game developers, it's not because of MIDI itself, which is simply a control mechanism and has no intrinsic sonic quality, good or bad. It's because of the inconsistent, usually low quality, fixed sample sets in the built-in synthesizer ROMs on most sound cards. DLS lets MIDI go back to being a timing, control, and note-triggering mechanism, as opposed to being a synonym for crappy-sounding game music . When MIDI is freed up to do its stuff, it can provide the granularity, malleability, and reaction time needed to make music react to what goes on in an interactive world.
As I mentioned, DirectMusic was conceptually built up from its specialized music-digesting system, the most controversial and confusing part of the SDK. This system is good at its original purpose, but that's not the whole story. It has a big side-benefit: a way to play and control segments of MIDI data, apply tempo maps and data filters, and concatenate them into other segments at musically-appropriate junctures (Figure 1). APIs such as the Miles Sound System, HMI's Sound Operating System, and DiamondWare's STK have already been doing this sort of thing (and more) under Windows despite MidiOut's limitations. All of these SDKs' developers are likely to be able to do more interesting things more reliably under DirectMusic.
DirectMusic Screen Shot